As Amazon Associates, we earn from qualifying purchases. This means we may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you if you click through and make a purchase.
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
If you are searching for legend flame legendflame 23 w free alternatives, you likely want a compact electric fireplace insert that fits small spaces. The original Legend Flame 23" model offers a narrow 23-inch width and crackling sound effects. It provides 1500W of infrared heat for rooms up to 400 square feet. You get remote control convenience and a realistic white birch log set. This unit is designed as a supplemental heater rather than a primary heat source. It plugs into a standard 120V circuit and includes a one-year limited warranty. The compact design makes it suitable for buyers who need a narrower unit than bulkier 28-inch options.
However, you might want something else for different reasons. You may prefer a wider 24-inch or 28-inch frame for a larger visual presence. Some buyers need multi-color flame options instead of the standard white birch logs. Others might prioritize specific installation types or different weight capacities for their floor. The alternatives listed here were chosen because their specifications overlap with the original product. They share key features like remote control, 1500W heating power, and infrared technology. These options provide similar functionality while offering variations in size, brand, and aesthetic details to suit your specific room layout and style preferences.
How each alternative compares
PuraFlame Western 23" Electric Fireplace
The PuraFlame Western 23" shares the 1500W heating capacity and remote control of the Legend Flame, but it is significantly wider at 33.9 inches compared to the Legend Flame's 23-inch width. This extra width allows for a larger flame display, yet it requires more floor space. Both units include crackling sound effects and operate as inserts. You should choose this model if you prioritize a wider visual presence over the compact footprint of the Legend Flame. The added width makes it less suitable for very narrow alcoves where the original model fits perfectly.
PuraFlame 24" Electric Log Set Heater
The PuraFlame 24" Electric Log Set is slightly wider at 24 inches compared to the Legend Flame's 23 inches, but it is lighter at 13.4 pounds versus 19.9 pounds. It offers the same 1500W heat output and remote control. A key difference is the multi-color flame feature, which the Legend Flame lacks. Both units provide crackling sounds and fit within the 24-inch and under category. If you want customizable flame colors and a lighter unit, this is a strong alternative. The Legend Flame remains better if you prefer a standard white birch log set and do not need color-changing effects.
PuraFlame Klaus 23" Electric Fireplace Insert
The PuraFlame Klaus 23" is heavier at 31.3 pounds compared to the Legend Flame's 19.9 pounds, though both share the 23-inch width designation. The Klaus measures 24.8 inches wide, making it slightly broader than the Legend Flame's 23-inch frame. It provides the same 1500W infrared heat and includes remote control and crackling sound effects. Both are insert-style heaters. You might prefer the Klaus if you need a sturdier build, as indicated by the higher weight. However, the Legend Flame is more compact and lighter, making it easier to position in tighter spaces without sacrificing heating performance.
LegendFlame Damon 28" Electric Fireplace Insert
The Legend Flame Damon 28" is significantly wider at 28.7 inches compared to the Legend Flame's 23-inch width. It offers the same 1500W heating capacity and remote control features. Both models include crackling sound effects and function as electric fireplace inserts. The Damon is designed for buyers who want a larger visual presence and do not have space constraints. If you need a narrower unit to fit into a smaller alcove, the original Legend Flame is the better choice. The Damon provides a more substantial look but requires more floor space and may not fit in areas where the 23-inch model is intended.
Giantex 28.5 Inch Black Electric Fireplace
The Giantex 28.5" Electric Fireplace is wider at 28.5 inches compared to the Legend Flame's 23-inch width. It includes a timer feature, which the Legend Flame does not list. Both units offer 1500W heat, remote control, and multi-color flame options. The Giantex is heavier at 25.7 pounds versus 19.9 pounds. If you value precise timer controls and a larger frame, this is a suitable alternative. The Legend Flame is preferable for buyers who need a narrower unit and do not require timer functionality. Both are versatile inserts, but the size difference is the primary deciding factor for your space.
Duraflame Electric Log Set Infrared Heater
The Duraflame Infrared Electric Log Set is much smaller, with a width of 20.7 inches compared to the Legend Flame's 23 inches. It is also lighter at 12.5 pounds. It provides infrared heat and remote control with crackling sounds. Unlike the Legend Flame, it does not list a wattage in the attributes, but it is designed for smaller rooms. The Duraflame is ideal for existing fireplaces where space is limited. If you need a compact, lightweight solution for a narrow opening, this model works well. The Legend Flame offers more robust heating power and a larger display for those who can accommodate its size.
| # | Product | Best for | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Legend Flame 23" Electric Fireplace Insert Best overall | smaller rooms needing a compact 23-inch heater | |
| 2 | PuraFlame Western 23" Electric Fireplace Best premium | small rooms needing ambiance and remote control | |
| 3 | PuraFlame 24" Electric Log Set Heater Best budget | small rooms up to 400 sq ft | |
| 4 | PuraFlame Klaus 23" Electric Fireplace Insert Also great | small rooms needing 23-inch crackling fireplaces | |
| 5 | LegendFlame Damon 28" Electric Fireplace Insert Also great | small rooms needing supplemental heat | |
| 6 | Giantex 28.5 Inch Black Electric Fireplace Best timer | timer-controlled heating | |
| 7 | Duraflame Electric Log Set Infrared Heater Best infrared | smaller rooms with existing fireplaces |
Legend Flame 23" Electric Fireplace Insert
Best for: smaller rooms needing a compact 23-inch heater
- Mounting Type
- Free Standing, Insert
- Width
- 23 inches
- Wattage
- 750W/1500W
- Coverage Area
- up to 400 square feet
- Control Method
- Remote Control
- Features
- Remote, Crackling Sound
This 23-inch electric fireplace insert heats rooms up to 400 square feet using a 1500W infrared heater. It features a remote control for easy operation and includes crackling sound effects for ambiance. The unit weighs 19.9 pounds and measures 20 inches high. It is CSA certified and comes with a one-year limited warranty. You get a polarized plug for standard 120V outlets. It serves as a supplemental heat source rather than a primary one.
- 1500W heating capacity for rooms up to 400 sq ft
- Includes remote control with 2 AAA batteries
- CSA certified for safety standards
- Crackling sound effect adds to the flame ambiance
- 23-inch width is narrower than the 28-inch and 28.5-inch competitors
- 19.9-pound weight is lighter than heavier log set alternatives
- One-year warranty is shorter than typical industry standards
- You need a compact 23-inch insert for a smaller space
- You want a unit with crackling sound effects
- You prefer a lightweight unit that is easy to move
- You require a wider 28-inch or larger display
- You need a primary heat source for a large home
- You want a warranty longer than one year
Verdict: LegendFlame 23" White Birch Electric Fireplace fits buyers who need a compact, 23-inch supplemental heater with sound effects. It is ideal for smaller rooms where a narrower unit is preferred over the bulkier 28-inch options available.
PuraFlame Western 23" Electric Fireplace
Best for: small rooms needing ambiance and remote control
- Mounting Type
- Insert
- Width
- 33.9 inches
- Wattage
- 750/1500W
- Coverage Area
- up to 400 sq. ft.
- Control Method
- Remote Control
- Features
- Remote, Crackling Sound
This PuraFlame insert offers 1500W of supplemental heat for rooms up to 400 square feet. It features a 23-inch opening with a black trim kit and measures 33.9 inches wide. You get three flame settings with variable brightness and a crackling sound effect. The unit includes a remote control and an adjustable thermostat. It sits on the floor and plugs into a standard outlet.
- 1500W heating output for up to 400 sq. ft.
- Includes remote control for easy operation
- Features crackling sound and variable flame intensity
- Adjustable thermostat for precise temperature control
- Heating coverage of 400 sq. ft. is lower than competitors offering 1000 sq. ft.
- Overall width of 33.9 inches is bulkier than standard 23-inch models
- Wattage options are limited to 750W and 1500W
- You need supplemental heat for a small to medium room
- You want a realistic flame effect with crackling sounds
- You prefer remote control operation over manual buttons
- You require a primary heat source for large spaces
- You need a unit narrower than 30 inches wide
- You want hard-wired installation instead of plug-in
Verdict: PuraFlame Western 23" Electric Fireplace Insert provides solid heat for smaller rooms but requires more floor space than slimmer alternatives. It suits buyers who value ambiance features like crackling sounds and remote control convenience over maximum heating coverage.
PuraFlame 24" Electric Log Set Heater
Best for: small rooms up to 400 sq ft
- Mounting Type
- Free Standing, Insert
- Width
- 24 inches
- Wattage
- 750W/1500W
- Coverage Area
- 400 square feet
- Control Method
- Remote Control
- Flame Color Options
- 6
The PuraFlame 24-inch electric fireplace insert offers 750W or 1500W heating for rooms up to 400 square feet. It features six flame colors with five brightness levels and includes a crackling sound effect. You get a remote control, a digital thermostat ranging from 60 to 82℉, and a timer. The unit weighs 13.4 pounds and fits standard fireplace openings. This model provides a focused heat source with adjustable ambiance settings.
- 1500W heating output for rooms up to 400 sq ft
- 6 flame colors with 5 brightness levels
- Includes remote control and crackling sound effect
- Thermostat adjustable from 60 to 82℉
- Heating capacity limited to 400 square feet
- Weighs 13.4 pounds, adding bulk to the unit
- Only one size option available at 24 inches
- You need a 24-inch insert for an existing fireplace opening
- You want adjustable flame colors and brightness levels
- You prefer using a remote control for settings
- You require heating for spaces larger than 400 square feet
- You need an insert wider than 24 inches
- You want a primary heat source for the whole home
Verdict: PuraFlame 24" Electric Fireplace Insert fits you if you want a compact 24-inch unit with 1500W heat and remote-controlled ambiance for a medium-sized room.
PuraFlame Klaus 23" Electric Fireplace Insert
Best for: small rooms needing 23-inch crackling fireplaces
- Mounting Type
- Insert
- Width
- 24.80 inches
- Wattage
- 750W / 1500W
- Coverage Area
- Up to 400 sq ft
- Control Method
- Remote Control
- Features
- Remote, Crackling Sound
The PuraFlame Klaus is a 23-inch electric fireplace insert with a black finish. It offers 750W or 1500W of supplemental heat for spaces up to 400 square feet. The unit features a crackling sound effect and a remote control for easy operation. You get three flame settings with variable intensity. The insert weighs 31.3 pounds and includes a resin log set for a realistic look.
- 1500W heater output for supplemental warmth
- Includes remote control for operation
- Crackling sound effect adds realism
- Three flame settings with variable intensity
- Heats up to 400 sq. ft., less than the 1,000 sq. ft. capacity of the duraflame option
- 23-inch width is narrower than the 28-inch and 28.5-inch inserts on the list
- Weighs 31.3 pounds, heavier than the PuraFlame Western 23-inch model
- You need a 23-inch insert for a specific opening
- You want crackling sound effects with your flames
- You prefer a black finish for your decor
- You require heating for areas larger than 400 square feet
- You need a wider unit than 23 inches
- You want a lighter appliance for easier placement
Verdict: PuraFlame Klaus 23" Black Electric Fireplace fits buyers who need a compact 23-inch insert with crackling sound effects. It is a practical option for small rooms where supplemental heat is sufficient.
LegendFlame Damon 28" Electric Fireplace Insert
Best for: small rooms needing supplemental heat
- Mounting Type
- Free Standing, Insert, Recessed
- Width
- 28.7 inches
- Wattage
- 750/1500W
- Coverage Area
- up to 400 sq. ft.
- Control Method
- Remote Control
- Features
- Remote, Crackling Sound
The Legend Flame Damon 28" is an electric fireplace insert with a black finish and glass front. It offers 1500W of supplemental heat for spaces up to 400 sq. ft. You get remote control operation, adjustable thermostat, and realistic flame effects with nine mood light settings. The unit supports free standing, insert, or recessed installation. It includes a crackling sound feature and CSA certification for safety.
- 1500W heating capacity for up to 400 sq. ft.
- Remote control for easy operation
- Nine mood light settings for ambiance
- Crackling sound feature enhances realism
- CSA Certified for safety standards
- Smaller heat coverage area of 400 sq. ft. compared to competitors offering 1,000 sq. ft.
- Heater cannot be used as a main heat source
- Requires 120V plug-in and cannot be hard wired
- You need supplemental heat for a small room up to 400 sq. ft.
- You want a black fireplace insert with a glass front
- You prefer remote control operation over manual switches
- You require a main heat source for your home
- You need coverage for areas larger than 400 sq. ft.
- You want a hard-wired installation option
Verdict: Legend Flame Damon 28" Electric Fireplace fits buyers seeking a cozy, supplemental heat source for smaller rooms with remote convenience and realistic flame effects.
Giantex 28.5 Inch Black Electric Fireplace
Best for: timer-controlled heating
- Mounting Type
- Recessed, Wall Mount, Freestanding
- Width
- 28.5 inches
- Wattage
- 750W / 1500W
- Heat Output
- 2559 BTU / 5118 BTU
- Control Method
- Remote Control, Manual
- Flame Color Options
- 3
This 28.5-inch electric fireplace insert offers 750W or 1500W heating. It features a timer that runs for 0 to 8 hours and three flame color options. The unit weighs 25.7 pounds and includes a remote control. It suits you if you need flexible installation modes like recessed or freestanding use with adjustable warmth settings.
- Timer function for 0 to 8 hours
- Three flame color options
- Remote control included
- 750W or 1500W heating modes
- 25.7 pound weight is heavier than lighter inserts
- 28.5-inch width is narrower than some 33-inch or 36-inch alternatives
- Only two heat settings compared to more granular controls
- You want a timer for automatic shut-off
- You need a 28.5-inch width for your space
- You prefer remote control operation
- You require a wider 33-inch or 36-inch unit
- You need more than two heat settings
- You prefer a lighter unit under 20 pounds
Verdict: Giantex 28.5" Electric Fireplace Insert fits you if you prioritize timer functionality and remote ease over maximum width or fine-grained heat adjustments.
Duraflame Electric Log Set Infrared Heater
Best for: smaller rooms with existing fireplaces
- Mounting Type
- Insert
- Width
- 20.52 inches
- Coverage Area
- Up to 1,000 sq ft
- Control Method
- Remote Control
- Features
- Remote, Crackling Sound
- Operating Modes
- Heating
This Duraflame infrared heater sits inside existing fireplaces to warm up to 1,000 square feet. It measures 20.7 inches wide and weighs 12.5 pounds. You control the heat, flames, and crackling sound with a remote. The unit offers independent flame and heat settings for year-round use. It suits those wanting supplemental heat with realistic visual effects.
- Infrared heating method for efficient warmth
- Covers areas up to 1,000 square feet
- Includes remote control for all settings
- Features realistic LED flames and crackling sound
- Independent controls for heat and flame effects
- Heater width of 20.7 inches is narrower than most 23-inch or 28-inch alternatives
- Weight of 12.5 pounds is lighter than bulkier insert models
- Limited to electric infrared heating only
- You need a compact heater for smaller spaces
- You want to add heat to an existing fireplace
- You prefer remote control operation
- You require a wider 23-inch or larger unit
- You need a wall-recessed installation option
- You prefer gas or wood-burning heat sources
Verdict: Duraflame Infrared Electric Log Set delivers targeted infrared heat for smaller rooms. It fits buyers who want a lightweight, remote-controlled heater for existing fireplaces.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | Legend Flame 23" Electric Fireplace Insert | PuraFlame Western 23" Electric Fireplace | PuraFlame 24" Electric Log Set Heater | PuraFlame Klaus 23" Electric Fireplace Insert | LegendFlame Damon 28" Electric Fireplace Insert | Giantex 28.5 Inch Black Electric Fireplace | Duraflame Electric Log Set Infrared Heater |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mounting Type | Free Standing, Insert | Insert | Free Standing, Insert | Insert | Free Standing, Insert, Recessed | Recessed, Wall Mount, Freestanding | Insert |
| Width | 23 inches | 33.9 inches | 24 inches | 24.80 inches | 28.7 inches | 28.5 inches | 20.52 inches |
| Wattage | 750W/1500W | 750/1500W | 750W/1500W | 750W / 1500W | 750/1500W | 750W / 1500W | – |
| Coverage Area | up to 400 square feet | up to 400 sq. ft. | 400 square feet | Up to 400 sq ft | up to 400 sq. ft. | – | Up to 1,000 sq ft |
| Heat Output | – | – | – | – | – | 2559 BTU / 5118 BTU | – |
| Control Method | Remote Control | Remote Control | Remote Control | Remote Control | Remote Control | Remote Control, Manual | Remote Control |
| Flame Color Options | – | – | 6 | – | – | 3 | – |
| Thermostat Range | – | – | 60 to 82℉ | – | – | 62°F–82°F | – |
| Features | Remote, Crackling Sound | Remote, Crackling Sound | Remote, Multi-Color Flames, Crackling Sound | Remote, Crackling Sound | Remote, Crackling Sound | Timer, Remote, Multi-Color Flames | Remote, Crackling Sound |
| Operating Modes | Heating | Heating | Heating | Heating | Heating | Heating | Heating |
| Color | Black | Black | Black | Black | Black | Black | Juniper |
| Operating Mode | Heater | Heater | Heater | Heater | Heater | Heater | Heater |
| Heating Method | – | – | – | – | – | – | Infrared |
| Fuel | Electric Infrared | Electric Infrared | Electric Infrared | Electric Infrared | Electric Infrared | Electric Infrared | Electric Infrared |
| Installation | Insert | Insert | Insert | Insert | Insert | Recessed, Insert | Insert |
| Heater | 750/1500W Heater | 750/1500W Heater | 750/1500W Heater | 750/1500W Heater | 750/1500W Heater | 750/1500W Heater | – |
| Dimensions | 9.5 × 23 × 20 inches | 8.8 × 33.9 × 26 inches | 9.8 × 24 × 19.9 inches | 8.78 × 24.8 × 21.4 inches | 11.6 × 28.7 × 21.3 inches | 6 × 28.5 × 21 inches | 8.66 × 20.7 × 12.6 inches |
| Weight | 19.9 pounds | – | 13.4 pounds | 31.3 pounds | – | 25.7 pounds | 12.5 pounds |
| Size | Nora 23" White Birch | 23" with trim | 24" | 23" without Trim | 28" without trim | 28.5-inches | 20.52"W x 8.73" D x 14.43" H |
| Model | EF290A-WB | – | EF511A | PuraFlame-Klaus | EF262B | GT51075-HW | DFI041ARU-2 |
Frequently asked questions
Which 23-inch electric fireplace is the best overall choice?
The Legend Flame 23" Electric Fireplace Insert is the top pick for smaller rooms. It measures 23 inches wide and weighs 19.9 pounds. This model offers 1500W of infrared heat and includes a remote control with crackling sound effects. Its compact size makes it ideal for spaces where bulkier units do not fit.
What is the best premium option in this list?
The PuraFlame Western 23" Electric Fireplace is rated as the best premium choice. It provides 1500W of heat and remote-controlled ambiance features like crackling sounds. Note that it is 33.9 inches wide, which is significantly larger than the 23-inch models. This extra width supports a broader flame display for enhanced visual appeal.
Is there a budget-friendly alternative to the Legend Flame?
The PuraFlame 24" Electric Log Set Heater is the best budget option. It features 1500W of heating power and remote-controlled multi-color flames. Weighing only 13.4 pounds, it is lightweight and easy to install. This 24-inch unit suits buyers who want compact supplemental heat without a high cost.
Which model offers the best timer functionality?
The Giantex 28.5 Inch Black Electric Fireplace is the best choice for timer control. It supports both recessed and freestanding installation. The unit includes remote operation and multi-color flame settings. Its 28.5-inch width provides a substantial presence, making it suitable for larger areas where scheduled heating is a priority.
Does any model use pure infrared heating for existing fireplaces?
The Duraflame Electric Log Set Infrared Heater is designed for this purpose. It uses electric infrared technology to deliver targeted warmth. Weighing just 12.5 pounds, it fits easily into existing fireplace structures. The unit includes remote control and crackling sound effects, offering a cozy atmosphere without the need for complex installation.
What is the lightest 23-inch fireplace on the market?
The PuraFlame 24" Electric Log Set Heater is the lightest option at 13.4 pounds. Although it is 24 inches wide, it remains very portable. It provides 1500W of heat and includes remote-controlled ambiance features. This makes it a practical choice for users who need a lightweight heater for smaller rooms.
Can I find a 28-inch fireplace with remote control?
Yes, the Legend Flame Damon 28" Electric Fireplace Insert fits this need. It measures 28.7 inches wide and provides 1500W of infrared heat. The unit includes remote control and crackling sound effects. It is designed for supplemental heating in smaller rooms, offering a balance of size and functionality.