As Amazon Associates, we earn from qualifying purchases. This means we may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you if you click through and make a purchase.
When the ice maker in a Frigidaire refrigerator stops making ice, starts leaking or begins grinding, the fix is usually a complete ice maker assembly swap rather than a repair call. The hard part is not the installation, which most listings put at 15 to 30 minutes with a screwdriver, but finding the right part. Frigidaire and its sister brands have used several different ice maker families over the years, and they are not interchangeable.
All six parts compared here are third-party replacements built to fit Frigidaire refrigerators, not parts made by Frigidaire. They fall into three families by part number. The 243297609 family, which also covers 243297613 and 243297606, uses a 6-pin harness and a 10-cube tray. The 241798224 family, which also covers 241642511 and 241798231, is the older and very common style. The 5304532555 family fits newer FFHI and FRSS models. Your first job is to find the part number on your old ice maker or your fridge model number. We compared listings and compatibility data rather than installing each part.
Frigidaire Replacement Ice Maker Lineup at a Glance
| Part | Maker | Main part number | Notable detail |
|---|---|---|---|
| Upgraded 243297609 Ice Maker Replacement | RUANBOQONG | 243297609 / 243297613 | 6-pin, 10-cube tray |
| 241798231 241798224 241798211 Ice Maker Replacement | REEPLAR | 241798224 / 241798231 | Built-in wiring harness |
| KITCHEN BASICS 101 | Kitchen Basics 101 | 241798224 / 241642511 | 8 cubes per cycle, 1-year warranty |
| 241798224 241798231 Refrigerator Ice Maker | Nurfosttek | 241798224 | Adjustable ice size claimed |
| 5304532555 Ice Maker Assembly | Budora | 5304532555 | 1-year warranty |
| Upgraded 243297613 243297609 243297606 Ice Maker | Cylrod | 243297613 / 243297609 | 6-pin, 10-cube tray |
The Models in Detail
Upgraded 243297609 Ice Maker Replacement Refrigerator Widely compatible: 243297613 Refrigerator ice maker replacement parts
Check price on Amazon Our score: 8.0/10
Best for: Fridges using the 243297609 family
Pros
- Covers 243297609, 243297613, 243297606
- 6-pin harness, 10-cube tray
- Screwdriver install in about 15 minutes
Cons
- Third-party RUANBOQONG part
- 6 to 12 hours before first ice
The Upgraded 243297609 Ice Maker Replacement Refrigerator part is made by RUANBOQONG for the 243297609 family. It lists 243297613, 243297606, 243297607, 243297603, 243297801, 243297901, 243298001, 243298501 and AP6995374 as parts it replaces, and it notes a rail on the right side for routing the wiring.
The tray has 10 molds and the harness is 6-pin, and the listing asks you to confirm that your existing harness is 6-pin before ordering. The body is ABS, described as stable at low temperatures. Installation is quoted at 15 minutes with a screwdriver, and the listing warns it takes 6 to 12 hours of running before the new unit produces ice normally. It lists fixes for no ice, leaks, noise, error codes and misshapen cubes. The specification sheet says “Number of Items: 11”, which is not explained anywhere else.
This fits owners whose old ice maker carries a 2432976 or 2432980 series number. If your part starts with 2417, it is the wrong family.
241798231 241798224 241798211 Ice Maker Replacement 241798224 ice maker compatible with SOME Frigidaire Electrolux Kenmore
Check price on Amazon Our score: 9.2/10
Best for: Older 241798224 and 241642511 fridges
Pros
- Long cross-reference list
- Built-in wiring harness
- Seller offers fit checks
Cons
- Third-party REEPLAR part
- Model list not in listing
The 241798231 241798224 241798211 Ice Maker Replacement from REEPLAR covers the older 241798224 family. Its cross-reference list is long, including 241798201, 5304456671, 241642501, 241642503A, 241798211, 241642511, 5303320545, 5304445222 and more, and it states clearly that it fits only some Frigidaire, Electrolux and Kenmore refrigerators.
It comes with a built-in wiring harness, and the listing describes a simple unplug-and-swap installation. It lists symptoms it fixes: no ice, noise and an ice maker that will not turn off. The listing does not include a fridge model list, but the seller offers to check compatibility if you send your model number.
This suits owners who know their part number is in the 241798224 family and want a straightforward replacement. If you would rather check your fridge model yourself, the Kitchen Basics 101 listing includes model numbers.
KITCHEN BASICS 101 Ice maker features 8 cubs per cycle and an automatic shut-off arm
Check price on Amazon Our score: 9.0/10
Best for: Owners who want model numbers listed
Pros
- Lists many fridge model numbers
- 8 cubes per cycle, shut-off arm
- 1-year warranty
Cons
- Dimension fields conflict
- Third-party part
The KITCHEN BASICS 101 241798224 replacement is sold under the Kitchen Basics 101 name by SupplyEdge. It makes 8 cubes per cycle and has an automatic shut-off arm. It replaces a long list of part numbers including 241798201, 241642501, 241798231, 241642511, 5304445222 and 5304456669.
Its biggest advantage is that the listing includes fridge model numbers, such as Frigidaire FRS26 and FRS6 series and Electrolux E23CS series, so you can check against the label inside your fridge. It lists dimensions of 4.5 by 4.75 by 11.3 inches in the features, while the specification field reads 1 by 1 by 1 inch, clearly a data error. It carries a 1-year no-questions warranty.
This is the easiest choice for anyone who can find their fridge model number but not the old part number. It serves the same family as the REEPLAR and Nurfosttek parts.
241798224 241798231 Refrigerator Ice Maker Extensively compatible with hundreds of models, such as E32AF75JPS0
Check price on Amazon Our score: 8.8/10
Best for: 241798224 fridges with EI23 or E32 models
Pros
- Named model examples
- Adjustable ice size claimed
- Only a 1/4-inch screwdriver needed
Cons
- Third-party Nurfosttek part
- Install time listed at 30 minutes
The 241798224 241798231 Refrigerator Ice Maker from Nurfosttek is another 241798224 family replacement. It names example compatible models, including E32AF75JPS and E32AF85PQS series and EI23CS35K series, and it replaces 241798201, 5304456671 and 241642501.
The listing mentions automatic water filling, a rapid ice cycle, automatic start and stop and adjustable ice size, as well as food-grade materials. Installation uses a 1/4-inch screwdriver in four steps and is quoted at 30 minutes. It lists 184 watts and 115 volts, which matches the REEPLAR specification.
It suits owners of the EI23 and E32 models it names. If your model is not named, the seller invites you to contact them before ordering.
5304532555 Ice Maker Assembly Compatible Please see product description for model compatibility!
Check price on Amazon Our score: 9.6/10
Best for: Newer FFHI and FRSS side-by-sides
Pros
- Covers 5304532555 and cross refs
- Long compatible model list
- 1-year warranty
Cons
- Third-party Budora part
- Few install details
The 5304532555 Ice Maker Assembly Compatible with Frigidaire refrigerators is made by Budora. It covers a newer family, with cross-references to AP7193288, 5304523840, 5304532194, 5304525923, 5304531891, 5304532196 and 5304532554.
The description lists compatible models such as FFHI1835VS and FRSS2323 and FRSS2623 series, and the listing names Electrolux, Frigidaire, Gibson, Kelvinator, Westinghouse and Kenmore as brands it may fit. It weighs 1.58 pounds and carries a 1-year warranty. The listing does not describe installation steps or the tray design.
This is the one for owners of FFHI and FRSS side-by-side models. It will not fit fridges using the 2432976 or 2417982 families.
Upgraded 243297613 243297609 243297606 Refrigerator Ice 243297613 refrigerator ice maker replacement for 243297609 243297606
Check price on Amazon Our score: 8.8/10
Best for: 243297613 owners wanting extra cross-refs
Pros
- Adds 243298101 and 243298401
- 6-pin harness, 10-cube tray
- ABS body for low temperatures
Cons
- Third-party Cylrod part
- 6 to 12 hours before first ice
The Upgraded 243297613 243297609 243297606 Refrigerator Ice maker replacement from Cylrod is close to identical to the RUANBOQONG part: a 10-mold tray, a 6-pin harness, an ABS body and a wire track on the right side. It lists 15 minutes for installation and 6 to 12 hours before normal ice production.
Its cross-reference list adds 243298101 and 243298401, which the RUANBOQONG list does not include. Listed dimensions are 10 by 3 by 4.92 inches, with 5 watts listed, the same as RUANBOQONG.
Choose it if your old part is 243298101 or 243298401, or simply as an alternative in the same family. If your harness is not 6-pin, neither of these parts is the right choice.
Matching a Model to Your Setup
- Old ice maker labeled 243297609, 243297613 or 243297606: Upgraded 243297609 Ice Maker Replacement from RUANBOQONG.
- Old part labeled 243298101 or 243298401: Cylrod Upgraded 243297613 Ice Maker.
- Older fridge with a 241798224 or 241642511 part: REEPLAR 241798231 Ice Maker Replacement.
- You can find your fridge model number but not the part number: KITCHEN BASICS 101, which lists models.
- Electrolux EI23 or E32 model with a 241798224 part: Nurfosttek 241798224 Refrigerator Ice Maker.
- FFHI or FRSS side-by-side: Budora 5304532555 Ice Maker Assembly.
Before You Buy
Find the part number on your existing ice maker, usually on a sticker on the side or back, and the model number on the label inside the fridge compartment. Match one or both against the cross-reference list before ordering. Turn off power and water before starting, and expect the new unit to take several hours to cool and start cycling. If you are also due for other upkeep, our guide to the Frigidaire Gallery air filter covers a part that is often replaced at the same time.
The listings do not say whether the water inlet valve, which is a common cause of no-ice problems, is included; none of them list it. Several have data errors in dimensions and item counts. Warranties are listed only for Kitchen Basics 101 and Budora. If your built-in ice maker is beyond repair, a standalone Frigidaire 33 lb ice maker is an alternative that sits on the counter.
FAQ
Are these genuine Frigidaire ice makers?
No. All six are third-party replacement parts designed to fit Frigidaire refrigerators and related brands.
How do I find my Frigidaire ice maker part number?
Remove the ice bin and look for a sticker on the ice maker itself. You can also use the fridge model number on the label inside the fresh food compartment.
Is 241798224 the same as 243297609?
No. They are different families. The 243297609 parts use a 6-pin harness and a 10-cube tray, while 241798224 parts are an older design.
Why is my new ice maker not making ice yet?
The 243297609 family listings say it takes 6 to 12 hours of operation before normal production starts.
Can I install a replacement ice maker myself?
The listings describe screwdriver installs of 15 to 30 minutes. Disconnect power first and follow the instructions supplied.
What if I want nugget ice instead?
These parts make standard cubes. For nugget ice, a countertop unit such as a Frigidaire nugget ice maker is the option.